Make no mistake: It was a good problem for the Orioles to have, needing so many roster spots this week to ensure all the drafting and development successes who would have otherwise been eligible for this year’s Rule 5 draft stayed in the organization.

But this isn’t some moment to exhale for the Orioles. They did the right thing and added the players they needed to. It just created another problem, though — and it’s one where if their luck stays what it has been (mostly crummy), it could have a significant impact on the 2027 season.

The seven additions they made — pitchers Michael Forret, Nestor German, Levi Wells, Patrick Reilly, and Braxton Bragg, plus outfielder Enrique Bradfield Jr. and infielder Aron Estrada — were all necessary. There’s no way to know whether the pending lockout will cancel the Rule 5 draft, and those players all have enough value that it would be foolish to risk losing them for nothing.

If Trey Gibson and Luis De León hadn’t debuted this year, they’d have been on this list, too. That group of nine players makes up nearly a quarter of the Orioles’ 40-man roster, which has just two spots open.

Advertise with us

Whatever good sleep the Orioles can get knowing these players are staying put will probably be shaken a bit by the reality that this, now, represents a meaningful part of their major league depth. That means they’re going to need them in 2027, and it’s unclear how ready they are to consistently contribute. As talented as these players are, that’s going to create some uncomfortable moments both as the Orioles build out their roster this winter and put it to use in 2027.

This doesn’t mean they’re a bunch of stiffs. Far from it. Forret and German fill up the zone with arsenals of pitches that can be league-average and have proven minor league track records over several years. Before his elbow injury in 2025, Bragg had graduated from being a command artist to one of the best starters in the minors as his velocity and pitch shapes advanced; he and Reilly, another pitcher on his way back from Tommy John elbow reconstruction surgery, showed they were healthy and kept their high ceilings in the Arizona Fall League. Wells’ addition, which comes after he missed most of the season after core muscle surgery, has a live arm and will probably now be a reliever full-time.

On the hitting side, Bradfield didn’t progress as the Orioles had hoped at Triple-A but had a .732 OPS in the second half and still looks capable of playing major league caliber defense, while Estrada is a switch-hitter who’s limited to second base but makes a ton of good contact.

It would have been a shame if the Orioles left any of these players unprotected. Homegrown pitching is the lifeblood of an organization, and this group represents an inflection point for the Orioles’ operation trying to bring that to Baltimore.

The real shame is that they were in this position to begin with. It was almost a foregone conclusion in the first half of the season that the Orioles would be buyers at the trade deadline simply because they had to move some of these players and get something that can help the big league team. It turned out they were so bad that they sold and reacquired Forret, a 2023 draftee who was part of the Shane Baz trade in December.

Advertise with us

But the Orioles mostly held tight to this group in the winter by choice, and in some ways that impacted the value of the players on the market.

The Orioles were never going to get fair value in a trade for a player other teams probably figured they could get for a couple hundred grand next month if the draft happens.

Pitcher Levi Wells (93) delivers a pitch in the spring training game against the Pittsburgh Pirates in Sarasota, Florida, earlier this year. (Ulysses Muñoz/The Banner)

That makes their presence on the roster fascinating to me. They’re all good players, and I imagine they’ll help the Orioles in the long-term. It’s just hard to envision how exactly they help the 2027 Orioles at this point.

We also learned Trevor Rogers declined his qualifying offer Tuesday, leaving the Orioles with Baz, Kyle Bradish and Brandon Young as their proven starters.

They’ll address that before the lockout, but my gut tells me there’s going to be someone from this group (De León and Gibson included) in the opening day rotation. I’ve been told all offseason that the Orioles still see De León as a starter, and I’d give him the best shot among this bunch. Gibson’s experience will give him a leg up, and German had a strong Triple-A season before a shoulder issue shut him down in August. Forret probably has some more work to do in Triple-A, while Bragg and Reilly have still never pitched at the level.

Advertise with us

Any of these guys can be eased into action in the bullpen if there’s a major league need, but when you factor in that Anthony Eyanson and Joseph Dzierwa will also start at Norfolk, we’re talking about the entirety of the major league rotation depth concentrated in this class of pitchers.

All of them being on the roster will mean the Orioles will have to get creative as they add this month in trades and free agency to address the pressing outfield and rotation needs, plus whatever they feel like needs to happen in the bullpen and behind the plate.

Second baseman Aron Estrada (79) waits ready at second base during a spring training game against the Detroit Tigers in Lakeland, Florida, earlier this year. (Ulysses Muñoz/The Banner)

Nothing is prohibiting them from doing so. There are still a handful of players they can take off the roster after Tuesday’s culling, and again, the players they added here are valuable, talented and important to the Orioles’ future.

It feels like a weird needle to have to thread. It would have been a bummer losing any of them. It’s also not exactly a victory to have amassed so much pitching depth to use for acquisitions to help a playoff push this past summer and never get the chance. And understanding these are all good players who need some seasoning, it’s important to know that being on the roster means the clock is ticking for them to help the Orioles win now.

That’s the goal. Having this many prospects to add to the roster this time of year is, too. But this is a month where the Orioles have to get better. This small victory of keeping these prospects can’t be the only one.