No one believed Shawn McIntosh could win.

Not the Democrats.

Not the Republicans.

Not the media.

Advertise with us

In fact, TMZ, CNN, Fox News and Newsweek called the Baltimore County Council District 5 race on election night for incumbent Nino Mangione, tying the Republican to his cousin, convicted killer Luigi Mangione.

But McIntosh, a Democrat who ran a publicly financed campaign and was outspent 5-to-1, declared victory over Mangione on Friday by 2,190 votes.

McIntosh’s win marks the first time in 32 years that northern Baltimore County will be represented by a Democrat. It ushers in a Democratic supermajority on the Baltimore County Council, mirroring the national blue wave, and signals that voters in the county’s purplest district — from Lutherville-Timonium and Cockeysville to the Pennsylvania state line — care more about brass tacks than brash acts.

McIntosh, 61, said if elected, she would ban data centers, lower the cost of living, restructure zoning, protect the Urban-Rural Demarcation Line (URDL) and prioritize land preservation. She joins the most diverse and progressive council Baltimore County has elected in recent memory.

“I think it was this perfect trifecta, frankly,” she said of her win. “It was my messaging resonating with people ... being deeply afraid of the Mangione name and ... to me, kind of the year of the woman and kind of the year of the Democrat.”

Advertise with us

Mangione positioned himself as a proudly MAGA candidate. As a state delegate, he opposed a 2023 law requiring that Medicaid cover “medically necessary gender-affirming treatment” and introduced a failed bill to ban “sexually explicit” books in public school libraries. A member of a well-known Baltimore family, Mangione did not respond to a request for comment. He congratulated McIntosh on her win in a social media post on Monday.

A lawn sign shows support for McIntosh’s campaign. (Jessica Gallagher/The Banner)

In contrast to his opponent, Mangione failed to convince voters that his development ties would not supersede his constituents’ concerns, said resident Thorne Gould.

“Where I am, above the URDL, is a pretty conservative, not a very flashy group, that’s tired of all the political theatrics that’s been happening,” Gould said.

The 77-year-old, a longtime registered Republican, voted for McIntosh.

Development fears

Questions about how much, if any, development in District 5 should occur were at the forefront of the race between McIntosh, Mangione and independent candidate Cory Shaffer.

Advertise with us

Joe Davies, who trains horses for steeplechase on an equestrian farm he owns in Monkton, voted for McIntosh over fears Mangione would cave to developers’ short-term economic interests.

“What concerned me about Nino is that — besides his background — I think he certainly would’ve been a lot more friendly to developers than Shawn, who has a lot better perspective on what makes Baltimore County special in this district,” he said.

Mangione was appointed to replace Wade Kach in May. During his six-month tenure on the County Council, Mangione hosted conversations between developer Mark Renbaum and Lutherville-Timonium residents over Lutherville Station, the controversial redevelopment project that residents fear will attract crime, overcrowd schools and ruin their quality of life.

Mangione addresses the crowd at his campaign kickoff event last year. (Heather Diehl for The Banner)

In September, council members unanimously passed a bill granting the proposed 325-unit mixed-use apartment complex access to state funding. Eric Rockel, vice president of the Greater Timonium Community Council, previously called the move “premature.”

Rockel declined to say for whom he voted, but said that he thought Mangione made progress on the issue.

Advertise with us

McIntosh said she thought Mangione’s push to unlock state funding for Lutherville Station without guaranteeing certain benefits for the community was a massive miscalculation.

“I think that sunk him,” she said. “If he had not waded into those waters, he could’ve won on his name recognition.”

October surprise gone awry

Late last month, Mangione began targeting McIntosh over a citation she received for driving while intoxicated.

McIntosh previously told The Banner that she misjudged how much she had to drink when leaving a holiday party in December 2024. She hit a curb, disabling her electric car, and called her husband to pick her up. But police arrived first, and she was arrested on charges of driving under the influence of alcohol.

In social media posts, Mangione blasted McIntosh for the incident, labeling her “dangerously liberal, extreme, and unfit for office!” He also criticized her decision to publicly finance her campaign, calling her “greedy” for using taxpayer dollars.

Advertise with us

Gould, who lives in My Lady’s Manor — an agricultural area spanning Monkton and Jarrettsville — said his friends and neighbors wanted to see results, not political grandstanding or negative campaign ads.

“I think people up here are looking for someone who’s gonna serve their interests,” he said. “Not what you’re gonna say, not beating your chest and saying how great you are, but what’s your record?”

Gould said Mangione’s campaign made him think about George Washington’s 1796 farewell speech, in which the nation’s first president warned Americans to beware of political factions.

A sign opposing data centers is parked outside an informational open house on data centers at the Urbana Volunteer Fire Department in Frederick in September. (Jessica Gallagher/The Banner)

“And those factions are the current political parties,” Gould said. “You can’t just bury your head and not do your job. A lot of Republicans like me assume [Mangione] didn’t win because Republicans switched, not because Democrats came out in greater force.”

McIntosh, who qualified for public financing by raising $15,000 from 150 small-dollar donors, did not accept money from political action committees, labor unions or businesses. She said it was a moral imperative for her to run a campaign not beholden to corporate interests.

Advertise with us

The attack ads referring to the DUI were devastating, she said, but she doesn’t regret owning what she calls one of the worst mistakes of her life.

“I did share my truth and I held my head up high when he tried to drag me through the mud,” McIntosh said. “And, in the end, I think that spoke volumes to people.”

A roll of voter stickers at a polling location on Election Day. (Ulysses Muñoz/The Banner)

21,000 voters

Every time someone told McIntosh they did not see her name on enough signs in District 5, she would repeat a mantra to herself: “Signs don’t vote.”

The mother of five said she kept the 21,000 votes she needed to beat Mangione at the forefront of her mind.

McIntosh exceeded that number by more than 500 votes, including ballots cast early, on Election Day, by mail and provisionally. Throughout the campaign, she knocked on tens of thousands of doors, reaching more than 21,000 voters.

Advertise with us

“We were the sixth-highest door knockers in the state two to three weeks before the election,” she said. “I stopped counting at that point.”

Davies said he admired how much McIntosh refused to believe those who doubted her ability, or any Democrat’s ability, to beat Mangione.

“She ignored that advice, kept her head down and really campaigned hard and went door-to-door,” the 64-year-old said. “I really, really admire that, especially in the face of the astronomical odds against her.”