On his way out of office, Baltimore County Councilman Pat Young is proposing two bills that would let a Halethorpe developer build more rental housing and allow for a gas station.

But neighbors, several state delegates and Young’s soon-to-be successor on the council want to hit “return to sender.”

“I don’t understand why we would want to extend anything else to this developer who has strained the local resources in the community, eroded public trust and have had a lack of accountability not only to the community but also to our county,” said Del. Aletheia McCaskill, a Gwynn Oak Democrat who testified against the bill at a County Council hearing Oct. 27.

The bills are up for a vote Monday evening. One would modify zoning requirements to allow a gas station to be built on the site. The other would allow a mix of student and nonstudent housing near the Halethorpe MARC station in the southwestern part of Baltimore County.

Advertise with us

The fight over what has been called the Southern Crossroads development is emblematic of battles across the county and state. Local and state leaders are pushing for more housing to grow their tax bases, keep younger residents from fleeing to cheaper locales in Pennsylvania and Delaware, and allow older ones to age in place by downsizing.

But residents and the delegates who represent them say this project is proceeding without community input and isn’t well connected to the colleges it would serve — the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, and Community College of Baltimore County, which are about a mile away. And the developer, they say, is asking for special exemptions others don’t get.

It’s unusual for state delegates to testify on local zoning matters, although they have come before the council over the past several years to talk about policies, including their views on expanding the council. Zoning is strictly the purview of council members, who decide how to classify each piece of land in the county every four years.

Del. Sheila Ruth of Catonsville said she heard complaints from neighbors that included construction crews driving across residents’ lawns as they try to make tight turns and workers loitering at the elementary school playground, alarming families with young children.

“They have consistently shown disregard for the needs of the community,” Ruth said.

Advertise with us

James Fraser, who represents the developer, H & H Rock Cos., said it’s the neighbors who have been difficult.

“They have appealed every single decision on this project for the past five years,” he told the council at a meeting last week. “We’ve heard what they asked for, and we are more than willing to do those things.” He said H&H Rock Cos. is willing to add recreational amenities and sidewalk repairs.

“Given the current housing crisis in the county and state, now is not the time to delay commonsense housing legislation,” Fraser said.

Although the final number of homes is not confirmed because the plan is being built in stages, H & H Rock is building the first 182 townhomes on the former Good Shepherd Services Campus, a school and treatment center for adolescents. Another 31 townhomes were approved by the county’s administrative law judge, and the community is appealing the decision.

Mark K. Levy is the owner of H & H Rock Co. An LLC that shares the same Elkridge address with the company is listed in campaign finance records as having given $4,000 to Young since 2021.

Advertise with us

Many other council members take donations from developers, who contributed heavily to Julian Jones’ successful campaign for county executive.

The Southern Crossroads development saga has unfolded since 2020 and has involved three Catonsville Democratic councilmen: Tom Quirk; Young, his successor; and incoming representative Paul Dongarra.

Dongarra and others want the council to wait three weeks until he takes office to proceed.

“It’s kind of clearly a case where we’re allowing the developer to steer a process in a hurried fashion,” Dongarra said.

Fraser insists the bill “is not a reward to us or any developer.” The bill, he said, commits the developer to community benefits while recognizing “market realities” — that students may want to live in housing that is not specifically earmarked for students and creating separate buildings for them creates an “artificial limit” that makes housing scarcer.

Advertise with us

Young said little about the bills he has proposed. “I think they can speak for themselves,” he said. “I don’t need to make any comment on it.”

Dongarra, who campaigned on a platform of responsible growth, acknowledges the county needs more housing and that this location could be a boon for those who want to take public transit and perhaps live without cars.

He said he wants the development to include money for amenities such as a bike trail, community center or community revitalization — that would represent 2-3% of the project’s value.

Fraser said the biggest benefit he brings is “fresh homes and a fresh look” to a sometimes forlorn part of Route 1, right off the Beltway. Fraser told the council his company would set aside about $10,000 a year over the first 10 years that can be earmarked for capital improvement projects.

Amending the zoning for a mix of residents makes the project viable, he said, adding the gas station would tie together a section of the development with oddly shaped lots that would be challenging to develop.

Advertise with us

“If we proceed with the development as is,” he testified at last week’s council hearing, “there will never be another opportunity to attract high-quality national tenants.”

Michael McCullough, president of the Halethorpe Improvement Association, said taxpayers should not have to fund developers’ zoning challenges.

“My condolences to Mr. Fraser for having bought a piece of property that he cannot develop the way he wants,” he said in his testimony. “But you can’t ask for special favors to change the zoning rule that will affect the entire county just for the benefit of your development.”

Fraser responded that buyer’s remorse is not at play and “this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.”

Young introduced two other bills in late October that helped Steve Whalen, who also donated to his campaign. One created a mixed-use overlay district, and the other provided incentives to developers to improve underused properties.

Advertise with us

“I just don’t think that this council should be passing all of these major zoning changes in the lame duck period when there’s going to be a new county executive in just over a month,” said Ruth, who testified against the bills.

Whalen has contributed $20,050 to Young since 2020. Young was elected to the County Council in 2022. Before that, he served as a state delegate representing Southwestern Baltimore County.

Young returned some of those donations when he ran for county executive this year using public financing and only small-dollar donations. He came in fourth.

In 2013, Whalen pleaded guilty to violating campaign finance laws stemming from $7,500 in illegal contributions to Quirk’s campaign. He was fined $58,000. It was Dongarra who noticed the irregularities and tipped off state prosecutors. In 2022, he ran against Young and lost.

Both men said they are open to a rapprochement, and they met last week to discuss future projects.