When Pauline Peacock’s parents heard their daughter’s good friend had cancer, they didn’t question whether they would help.

Lexi Thomas seemed to be a “bright girl with a great personality” who could have done anything with her life, said Katherine “Kate” Peacock, Pauline’s mom.

“Everyone wants to rally around her and help her out any way they can, because especially a young person shouldn’t have to go through that much,” Kate Peacock said.

The couple, who live in Laurel, donated roughly $3,000 through GoFundMe and other fundraisers around 2017. They believed they were helping Thomas pay for novel medical care. They only learned earlier this year that Thomas, who went to Our Lady of Good Counsel High School in Olney with their daughter, had been lying for over a decade about her supposed illness.

Advertise with us

“I’m not sure what led her down that path,” Kate Peacock said. “For me, I just feel sorry for her, but I also feel upset for what she did to other people. … It’s just very sad and disappointing.”

Thomas, 34, was arrested Thursday after a Howard County grand jury indicted her on two felony charges: theft up to $25,000 and theft up to $10,000. A bail review is scheduled Monday morning in Howard County Circuit Court. The indictment lists about two dozen victims, including Kate and Pauline.

Her attorney, Max F. Maccoby, declined to comment Friday.

The charges came after a recently released podcast series, “The Lexi CON,” and her husband’s annulment filing, unearthed allegations that Thomas concocted an elaborate fraud to convince friends, family and online followers that she was battling a rare form of blood cancer since 2014. Thomas was able to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars for her alleged treatment.

The Peacocks first heard through friends in May that Thomas’ story was bogus — and the situation became more serious soon after when police investigators reached out to them. They hadn’t been in regular contact with Thomas since 2017, when she and Pauline Peacock cut ties.

Advertise with us

Pauline Peacock had grown suspicious of Thomas’ story over the years, her parents said. She questioned why she couldn’t visit her friend in the hospital and how Thomas had the energy to go out partying all the time. And why was everything a clinical trial? Some things just didn’t add up, her parents said.

It was around the same time Thomas started dating her husband, Gavin Hannan, which also introduced tension in the friendship. Pauline Peacock pulled back, and she lost mutual friends over the decision, her parents said.

Pauline Peacock told her parents that something just didn’t feel right about Thomas’ situation, but didn’t elaborate at the time. How does a girl in her young 20s accuse a friend of faking cancer? She didn’t have any proof.

When Kate Peacock, learned the truth, she apologized to her daughter.

“I felt bad that she couldn’t have said that — at least just throwing it out there, and then at least it starts planting seeds, and then as you plant the seeds and the garden grows, your eyes open up,” Kate Peacock said.

Advertise with us

Even after the friends two stopped talking, Thomas occasionally texted Kate Peacock and her husband, Bert Peacock, on holidays. She felt a “kinship” with Bert because he also had cancer, Kate Peacock said. He’d ask her for updates on her treatments.

“It’s very frustrating because there’s people out there that really need help from people, and when you look at this, it’s like, ’Are you for real? Are you telling me the truth?’” said Bert Peacock, who was diagnosed in 2011. “It doesn’t help the cancer community knowing that this is what went down with Lexi.”

The couple lost money, but they are more interested in vindication for their daughter, they said. The Peacocks hope some of their daughter’s former friends return to apologize and acknowledge she was right to step back.

As for the other victims? The Peacocks aren’t sure what justice looks like for Thomas’ family and friends, the people who lost more than money and were most deeply deceived through the years. One Howard County woman left a quarter of her estate to Thomas, believing she had cancer.

Bert Peacock questions whether Thomas was able to pull off the scheme by herself or if others were involved.

Advertise with us

“If nothing else, maybe if other people that are thinking about doing this, maybe they’ll think twice, because it’s going to come out eventually,” Kate Peacock said. “She made a really good run of it.”

Baltimore Banner reporter Julie Scharper contributed to this article.