Frank and Betsy Schindler were among those hoping the two-day hearing this week in the Archdiocese of Baltimore’s bankruptcy filing would resolve the case after three years and millions of dollars in legal fees.

Immediately, it became clear the couple who have helped their fellow survivors of sexual abuse would have to wait a little longer.

A suspicious package left at the Edward A. Garmatz U.S. Courthouse on Thursday led to an evacuation, and for a few minutes, no one was sure if the hearing would go on. It did, but the additional wait and uncertainty were emblematic of the frustrations the Schindlers and hundreds of fellow survivors have endured.

“What this does is delay people’s ability to recover from their trauma,” Frank Schindler said after a five-hour hearing that did not offer any resolution. “All of us have some form of PTSD, and this really isn’t helping anything.”

Advertise with us

On Friday, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Michelle Harner wrapped up a two-day hearing in the sprawling, complicated case involving the first Catholic diocese in the United States. Harner neither immediately ruled on several outstanding issues, nor set a date for when the parties would reconvene.

The archdiocese has already reached a conditional, tentative settlement with a committee representing survivors in the bankruptcy case.

Betsy Schindler, a member of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, speaks with other associates outside the Edward A. Garmatz United States District Courthouse on Thursday. (Ulysses Muñoz/The Banner)

Church leaders have said that more than $400 million could be available for survivors. But the case is not resolved, and negotiations are continuing with other parties — the insurance companies as well as the parishes, schools and other affiliated entities.

The judge has been exasperated with the pace, saying she has become physically upset thinking about attorney fees while survivors have not yet seen a cent.

“Regardless of why we are here, time is running out,” Harner said. “We have to someway get resolution.”

Advertise with us

Lawmakers passed the Child Victims Act of 2023 after the Maryland Office of the Attorney General documented how 156 priests and others perpetrated “horrific and repeated abuse” as church leaders turned a blind eye.

The act eliminated time limits for survivors to sue and allowed them to file lawsuits against institutions that enabled or covered up abuse.

But two days before it took effect, the archdiocese filed for bankruptcy in September 2023.

The bankruptcy filing prompted hundreds of survivors who have alleged abuse in rectories, parishes, and schools to file claims. Already, about two dozen of them have died.

About a half dozen asked the judge to modify a stay on litigation so lawsuits they filed in state court could move forward.

Advertise with us

Several of the attorneys compared the case to chipping away at the stone in a boulder. The judge, though, seemed like she had heard enough.

“The boulder needs to crack,” Harner said.

Auxiliary Bishop Adam Parker spoke at the end of the two-day hearing, lauding the “significant progress” made toward accomplishing the goal of compensating survivors.

Sexual abuse survivors Teresa Lancaster, left, and Erin Maze arrive at the Edward A. Garmatz United States District Courthouse on Thursday. (Ulysses Muñoz/The Banner)

The parishes, schools and other entities have made a “substantial offer.” Parker reiterated that more than $400 million has been put forward toward compensating survivors.

“The money is on the table. It’s there,” Parker said. “Survivors could be paid in the first quarter of 2027. I would love to see that happen.”

He said his boss, Archbishop William Lori, the head of the archdiocese, also wants them to be paid.