BOSTON — Adley Rutschman walked into the unfamiliar clubhouse on Tuesday afternoon, about 24 hours after he received a call at a movie theater alerting him that his Orioles tenure was over.
He looked around momentarily, then saw his large Orioles duffle bag, full of his baseball equipment, in the corner. The nameplate above his locker read Adley Rutschman, 31 — a new number in a new city. The locker, which was partially full of gloves and hats as clubhouse attendants hurriedly unpacked for Rutschman, was also full of Red Sox jerseys.
“I feel like I’m still kind of digesting a bit right now,” he said.
Ceddanne Rafaela, one of Boston’s outfielders and suddenly Rutschman’s teammate, walked over to shake his hand. Then Rutschman reached into his locker to pick out a shirt. He settled on a moisture-wicking Red Sox tee and a dark blue hat with a red “B” on it — the iconic Boston mark.
And shortly after, Rutschman jogged up the dugout steps, said “Hey, guys,” to a few well-wishing Red Sox fans, and started the newest twist of his life.
All of this in about 24 hours — from buying tickets to “Spider-Man: Brand New Day” with his friends Colton Cowser, Gunnar Henderson and Ryan Mountcastle to picking up and moving north. It was hard to describe at this early juncture, and during a conversation at his locker, his eyes grew red with tears thinking of those he leaves in Baltimore.
“I felt an unbelievable amount of love,” Rutschman said of Baltimore, from the fans, organization, teammates and total strangers. “Just reflecting over the last 24 hours, getting drafted, to my debut, to two playoff teams, just the excitement and love that I felt while I was there, I’m going to be forever grateful for that. It’s just a lot of emotion, and all love.”
There can be much debate over Mike Elias’ decision to trade Rutschman, a franchise cornerstone. The fact it was to the Red Sox, a division rival, will only add to it.
On one end, Rutschman’s contract was due to expire at the end of 2027. The Orioles received three highly rated prospects, catcher Carlos Narváez and a player to be named later from the Red Sox. Elias maximized the return rather than allowing a player to potentially leave in free agency for nothing.
On the other end, Rutschman is not just any player. The 28-year-old represented hope for baseball in Baltimore when he was drafted first overall in 2019. He was a franchise centerpiece, and by parting ways with him now, it closes a chapter earlier than expected — and without a postseason win, the chapter feels somewhat incomplete.
“In an ideal world, I would’ve loved to achieve that ultimate goal with the Orioles in the time I was there, be able to win a World Series and do that with that group of guys,” Rutschman said, “and we came up short.”
Rutschman’s agent, Dan Vertlieb, declined to comment when asked if there had been contract negotiations and where they might have gone wrong. Elias also declined to comment.
Whether Rutschman declined extension talks does not change how he feels about the team.
“You’re saying goodbye to a lot of really close, lifelong friends, and that’s tough,” he said. “I think as a baseball player you understand it’s part of the game. Saying goodbye sucks, but you understand what it is. It happens.”
Rutschman became close friends with so many in that Orioles clubhouse. His goofy personality meshed well with those other goofy ballplayers. They watched movies, discussed TV shows, golfed together in the offseason and had a good time.
There is no forgetting how May 21, 2022, felt in Baltimore — for fans and Rutschman himself. He reached the plate to catch the top of the first inning, and with his glove on his left hand and his mask in his right hand, the fresh-faced rookie making his debut slowly spun around, taking in Camden Yards.
“A lot of great memories,” Rutschman said, and that is right near the top.
He became a three-time All-Star, and while he regressed in 2025 with injuries and underperformance as factors, Rutschman rebounded this year. He’s currently on the injured list with left wrist inflammation. He said he has begun swinging, is playing catch and is likely nearing a rehab assignment.
Rutschman expected that rehab assignment to come with Triple-A Norfolk, where the once-top prospect spent his final months of minor league life. Instead, as Rutschman was preparing to step into the movie theater on his off day, a phone call came. It was Elias.
Rutschman has been around long enough now to know anything can happen at the trade deadline.
“I’ve seen it for the last couple years,” he said. “You see it with guys you’ve played with, and one day they’re there, and one day they’re not.”
This time, Rutschman said, “it was my name that was called.”
Rutschman said Elias is a “really good dude and he’s really good at his job, and I have a lot of respect for him and what he does, and the tough decisions that he has to make. He’s got to do what he thinks is best, and what’s best for the organization. Just talking to him, it wasn’t an easy conversation to have, but we have a good relationship, and just thankful for the time and memories that we were able to share for a great organization.”
By this time, Rutschman was in the home dugout at Fenway Park. He had walked onto the field, played catch, and then found this Banner reporter who shipped up to Boston to see how this franchise player looked in the colors of a rival organization.
Rutschman sat on the bench, catcher’s mitt on the railing. He looked out at his new surroundings. He made sure to say how special Camden Yards is, but there’s no denying the majesty of this baseball cathedral.
“There’s a lot of history with Baltimore, a lot of history here,” he said. “Stepping into a new environment and a new scene, I’ve played on the opposing side here, and you know the energy the ballpark brings. I’m excited to see where I fit in here and what my role is and how I fit into this group. My job is to fill in and serve the best I can.”
There were no tears in his eyes now. It was about two hours since he arrived. It was about 28 hours since he was traded. This isn’t easy, by any means. But Adley Rutschman is now a Boston Red Sox player, and he has no choice but to look forward to what is ahead.
“You make adjustments,” he said, “you roll with it.”
And with that, Rutschman stood up. He wore red, not orange. He smiled. Then he ducked his head down the dugout steps to his new home clubhouse.
Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.