Schaefer, O’Malley, Dixon, Schmoke, Pugh, Scott, Young, Rawlings-Blake.
When it comes to Baltimore’s leadership, you have thoughts.
At a forum hosted by The Baltimore Banner this year, we asked Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott to rank his predecessors. His list was topped by his mentor, Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, ended with the oft-lauded William Donald Schaefer and seemed meant to provoke.
“I like all the smoke,” Scott said at the time.
And provoke it did.
“What arrogance on the Mayor’s part to rate his predecessors!” Banner commenter Christine M. said. “I am offended on their behalf.”
We suspect some of you secretly enjoyed the discussion. After calling us “unserious,” former state Sen. Jill Carter used AI to generate a list of her own, ranking the mayors on their performance on civil rights issues. We love that idea, minus the unserious AI.
More than 1,000 of you submitted ranked lists, and below is your collective power ranking of the best (and worst) modern mayors of Baltimore.
1. William Donald Schaefer
It’s little surprise that the four-term mayor turned governor topped your list, even if Scott is not a fan. Schaefer took the top spot in 48% of votes, and commenters credited his bold vision for Baltimore.
Schaefer had his share of haters, however.
Scott clarified a remark he made in his initial ranking about how checks written by Schaefer too often bounced. Scott pointed to agreements signed by Schaefer for payments in lieu of taxes that do not expire. Scott also noted that population declined during Schaefer’s term and cited his sale of Friendship International Airport, now Baltimore-Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport.
“That doesn’t look like it was a smart thing for the city to do now,” Scott said.
2. Kurt Schmoke
A close second in your ranking was Kurt Schmoke, the first Black person elected as Baltimore mayor, serving from 1987 to 1999. Schmoke’s policies were ahead of their time — he advocated for decriminalization of drugs — but he also served during a difficult period. The city saw a rise in violence during his tenure.
Schmoke was the second-place choice of 42% of voters.
3. Martin O’Malley
Readers ranked Martin O’Malley, the mayor from 1999 to 2007, in the same position as Scott did. Scott said his answer was guided by his experience as a Black youth in Baltimore when city police routinely cleared corners for little to no reason.
He credited O’Malley, however, for professionalizing city government by adopting modern data tracking.
“You know how personally me and that man don’t get along,” Scott added later. “The fact that I didn’t rank him last tells you something.”
Of voters, 34% placed O’Malley in third position.
4. Brandon Scott
Voters were highly divided on Scott, the mayor since 2020. About 21% selected him as their top pick — the same percentage who chose him to be last.
Scott has overseen the city during a decline in violence that has attracted national attention. Homicides fell 24% in 2023, 21% in 2024 and 31% last year. Nonfatal shootings fell more than 50% from 2023 to 2025.
He’s also found himself at the center of controversy. His decision this year to cut off the inspector general’s direct access to city records was reversed by a court after a legal battle.
Potentially transformational proposals to replace the Harborplace pavilions and put Light and Pratt Street traffic on a road diet are soon due for consideration.
5. Stephanie Rawlings-Blake
Results were middling for Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, the mayor from 2010 to 2016. One-third of poll respondents ranked her in fifth position.
Rawlings-Blake’s tenure was upended by unrest in the wake of the death of Freddie Gray, who was injured while in police custody. Outraged residents took to the streets in protest, and Rawlings-Blake drew severe criticism for her response.
6. Sheila Dixon
Sheila Dixon, the former City Council president who served as mayor from 2007 to 2010, has an almost cultlike following among supporters who appreciate her hands-on approach and efforts to beautify the city.
City residents have not forgotten, however, her 2010 guilty plea to perjury charges that ultimately forced her from office. Multiple bids to win the job back have been unsuccessful.
Poll takers agreed Dixon did not top the list, but they were divided on where she belonged, with most placing her from third to seventh.
7. Bernard C. “Jack” Young
Bernard C. “Jack” Young, mayor from May 2019 to December 2020, assumed the post when Catherine Pugh resigned in the face of an investigation into self-dealing. He sought to win a full term but lost in 2020, trailing Scott, Dixon and others.
Voters resoundingly agreed Young belonged toward the bottom of the list, with more than half placing him in one of the last two positions.
8. Catherine Pugh
There’s not much more to say about Catherine Pugh, who resigned in 2019 amid questions about a children’s book she produced called “Healthy Holly.” The book was marketed and sold directly to nonprofit organizations, many of whom did business with the state and city. Pugh pleaded guilty to federal charges and served two years in prison.
Two-thirds of voters ranked Pugh in the bottom two slots.






Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.