Noncitizens who live in New Carrollton are eligible to vote in municipal elections.

They’re currently able register to vote on Election Day, and the town of more than 13,000 people does not record their names in a voter roll. But that could soon change.

New Carrollton Council member Agnelli Sybel Malavé is introducing two pieces of legislation, a charter amendment and a city code ordinance, that would effectively eliminate same-day voter registration for noncitizens and create a database containing their names.

The measures do not disenfranchise noncitizens in city elections, but the incoming mayor, Briana Urbina, believes the bills could discourage them from participating.

Advertise with us

The charter amendment would require residents who are not registered with the Prince George’s County Board of Elections to register with the city clerk at least 21 days before an election. Because noncitizens can’t register to vote with the county, the change would end same-day registration for them.

The ordinance would require New Carrollton to maintain a municipal election register, moving away from roll-less voting system currently in place.

Malavé’s proposed legislation is on the agenda for Wednesday’s 7 p.m. council meeting, following the swearing in of Urbina, who is leaving her seat on the five-member council.

If approved, Urbina has said she plans to veto “any effort to amend the city charter to remove voting rights for all residents.”

Malavé does not claim that voter fraud has occurred in New Carrollton, but her proposals come as President Donald Trump’s unsupported claims of voter fraud and aggressive approach to immigration enforcement have stoked fear within immigrant communities, causing some to retreat from public life.

Advertise with us

“We wanted a process that would be structured in such a way to ensure the integrity of the elections,” Malavé said.

Noncitizens cannot vote in federal elections, but a growing number of local governments have expanded voting rights to residents regardless of citizenship status. At least 22 municipalities across the country allow noncitizens to vote in local elections, including 17 in Maryland. D.C. also allows noncitizens to vote in elections for local office.

Malavé said she and council Chair Duane Rosenberg drafted the proposed legislation earlier this year and presented it during two public hearings in April. She said they implemented significant changes since then based on feedback from residents.

“Part of the argument that we want to present is that it’s a privilege that New Carrollton is giving residents that are not allowed to vote in state elections to have a voice in New Carrollton,” Malavé said. “But we should be able to set the guidelines and the requirements for that privilege, and that’s what this legislation stipulates.”

Urbina countered, saying the city has held two elections under its current law, and the Board of Elections has not identified problems with the process. She worries that the proposed restrictions could discourage participation, particularly among immigrant families.

Advertise with us

“This is the third time that council member Malavé has brought forth legislation to restrict all-resident voting,” Urbina said. “This version looks very different from the version she presented in April, but I think it’s problematic on several fronts.”

Urbina takes issue with the proposal to create an official list of people registered to vote in New Carrollton for fear that the database could be used by federal immigration agencies.

To her knowledge, Urbina said, New Carrollton was one of the first municipalities to implement an election system without voter rolls.

“However, many municipalities are now trying to adopt our process of having roll-less voting because of concerns around immigration and ICE,” she said. “So we are going backward, in my opinion.”

She proposed a compromise that would preserve same-day registration and require the city to destroy the temporary voter roll after election results are certified. She said that proposal was rejected.

Advertise with us

Janelle Wong, a University of Maryland professor and director of its Asian American Studies program who researches noncitizen voting and modern suffrage movements, echoed Urbina’s concerns about eliminating same-day registration for noncitizens.

“Restricting same-day registration to state-eligible voters or citizens contradicts the goal of maximizing turnout among all residents,” Wong said, adding that “The issue really is how do you be both inclusive and protect from voter fraud, but also not scare people from democracy?”

Urbina pointed to neighboring Cheverly as an example of potential risks. The conservative American Center for Law and Justice said it obtained the town’s voter registry through a public records request and had identified noncitizens on the rolls.

Malavé said the proposed voter roll is a necessary safeguard and that other municipalities with “all resident voting” maintain voter registration records. She emphasized that voters’ addresses won’t be included in the city’s rolls.

“We believe that the requirements that are being added in this legislation respond to the concerns of residents that were critical faults with the legislation that was approved in 2024,” Malavé said. “The lack of records, the lack of requirements, were really concerns with residents.”

Advertise with us

Under the proposed ordinance, the city clerk would record the names of residents who register directly with the city into a municipal voter roll. The chair of the city’s Board of Elections would then obtain the county’s voter registry and merge it with the city’s register, eliminating duplicate names.

The ordinance also says the city clerk would overwrite the existing register with an updated version after each election, leaving only one version and no historical copies.

Urbina doesn’t think that’s satisfactory.

She believes ICE could simply request the county’s voter roll, compare it to the town’s voter roll and easily identify any noncitizens.

Urbina has pledged to veto the legislation if it passes. The council can override her with a supermajority, but Urbina said she plans to pursue an injunction challenging a law that would implement different registration requirements for noncitizens.

Have a tip for our Prince George’s County reporters? Tell us here.