There was a moment on Election Day when I was hopeful, albeit cautiously, that the Davids of the world were beginning to get their licks back on the Goliaths, one tiny flung pebble at a time.
The “blue wave” results of the midterm elections were a sign that the voice of the people, especially those outside of the usual power structure, could be overwhelmingly heard and heeded. Democracy worked, even as some felt those powers-that-be were striving hard to stop it.
I was feeling very positive about the world in general and was consequently so upbeat about the beleaguered but tireless residents of Poppleton, who petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to hear their case against the out-of-town company whose promised development in the neighborhood stalled for decades. Their neighborhood is a shadow of its former self, and the people, feeling let down by everyone involved, just wanted to make it right.
I wanted the Baltimoreans to find a victory in this frenzied season of optimism.
But that was not to be. The petition was denied last week, and I shed actual tears because it seemed like a signal that the little guys, like the residents, just can’t win against companies, governments and legal powers like eminent domain, which takes private land and homes under the guise of providing a public benefit. That might be the most Goliath factor in this story. It’s tiring. But then I talked to the people fighting for Poppleton and was reminded that even in the worst of times, you gotta keep reloading that slingshot.
“I don’t lose the hope,” said Sonia Eaddy, president of neighborhood association Poppleton Now. She has been part of the fight for two decades against La Cité, the developer that has held residents in a sad limbo.
Read More
I found Eaddy’s statement shocking, given how often the residents have been played like Charlie Brown trying to kick the football Lucy keeps snatching away. Of all the development that was supposed to happen, only two apartment buildings have been completed. Residents feel abandoned by the city. The money for a promised and much-needed grocery store was reallocated to other projects. Homes have been lost.
But not hope.
“It’s something that we can learn from, how to pivot, as long as it seems to be another avenue that we could look at,” said Eaddy, who was one of the plaintiffs in the case. She said she was initially angry at the dismissal, though those involved knew that the Supreme Court petition was unlikely to be heard. “So much of a void had been left. They had us living with high grass and weeds, people saying it’s a dumping ground. There are no longer houses there. You’re living next door to a vacant. They gutted Poppleton out.”
La Cité did not respond to a request for comment.
Mayor Brandon Scott’s office responded with a statement saying that while it agreed with the court’s ruling that the actions didn’t amount to taking property, “the City is by no means content with the status quo with respect to the unfulfilled promises and unmet expectations of the neighborhood’s residents.” The office added that it hoped to identify a path forward to “see Poppleton flourish,” with or without the current development partners.
I grew up in Northwood, another Black Baltimore neighborhood that has its issues, like some crime, but has also seen positive development, like the Northwood Commons shopping center and all the expansion across Hillen Road at Morgan State University. I cannot imagine working so hard for my own place only to see the neighborhood crumble around it.
Perhaps that’s what fuels the residents, as they are not helpless, said Nicole King, a University of Maryland, Baltimore County, professor who has worked with Poppleton as a researcher and supporter and helped the residents refine and focus their petition. “The fight is always worth it, even if you don’t win. I learned it from them, a relentlessness,” she said.
Tom Prevas, the attorney who took the case to the Supreme Court, said he had similar hopes for the decision, but mused that the national voting results I held so tightly to as a good omen really were a sign. “What the election is trying to say is that we really do care, that people care about all of us and not just the special people,” Prevas said.
People all over the city who have been following the story do really care. “Something about this situation really sticks with people. It feels like such a gross injustice, something that’s hard to tolerate,” Prevas said.
The growing media attention is part of what gives Eaddy optimism. “Reading the articles that came out, I feel like there is a new beginning from the comments,” she said. “We’ve made enough awareness with social media and we’ve won public opinion. I feel we are now at a beginning.”
These residents have been locked in limbo for more than 20 years with no satisfying answers, and it’s discouraging. The Poppleton group comprises Black working-class people who have dealt with a lot of broken promises. No one in power expected they’d have any clue how to fight back. Can you imagine developers treating the residents of Roland Park this way? I sure can’t.
King remembers a conversation with a resident whose child was confused about what was happening around them. “She said, ‘I thought they meant development with us in it.’ Why do you have to be kicked out for nice stuff to come into your neighborhood?”
So what next? Eaddy said they could file their suit again, knowing it might take a while. They could also bring a suit against the city or force a breach-of-contract suit against the developer. However they proceed, they’ve decided to move forward. And that’s a statement in itself.
“People want to rebuild their community. They know they can’t get the past back. They want to build the future,” King said. “The people and humans at the center of this debacle are the most important.”
As I was researching this story, I heard some positive news from that national election I’d been hopeful about. Scott Colom became the first Black U.S. senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction, even after his opponent prematurely declared victory. Sometimes the Goliaths don’t see you coming. And that’s when you strike.
“I just see that the battle is not over,” Eaddy said. I believe her. Keep those pebbles coming.






Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.