Chris Van Hollen stood before friendly Democrats in Annapolis, gathered over bagels and coffee to hear him talk.
It was 2024, a year after the brutal Oct. 7 Hamas attacks. When questions turned to Israel’s devastating war in Gaza, the room went cold.
Half of those present fiercely supported Israel’s right to defend itself, while the rest were angry over the mounting cost in Palestinian lives.
“You should be able to recognize the horror of Oct. 7 and understand that trauma,” said Van Hollen, reaching for middle ground. “We should also be able to understand the trauma of innocent Palestinians in Gaza. We should be able to have our collective humanity understand it.”
In the two years since that breakfast meeting, Van Hollen has become one of the Senate’s leading critics of Israel’s government and its war.
He boycotted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s appearance in Congress, condemned settler violence in the West Bank and questioned the influence of the pro-Israel political action group AIPAC in American elections.
Read More
No issue separates Van Hollen and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer as much as Israel as they vie to be the next majority leader.
“I have many jobs as leader,” said Schumer, who is Jewish, in a widely reported speech in February, “and one is to fight for aid to Israel — all the aid that Israel needs.”
Van Hollen has focused his bid for Senate leadership on issues that motivated voters in the midterm election: affordability, ending President Donald Trump’s war in Iran and holding the president’s administration accountable.
“People are sick and tired of an economy that’s rigged against working people and stacked in favor of the very wealthy, the billionaire class, and big corporations,” he said.
But shifting American views on Israel could help Democratic senators decide how to vote Dec. 1, when they choose the next majority leader. Van Hollen may represent that change as well as anyone in Congress.
If there were any doubt about where he stood, he made the connection clear days before he announced his decision to challenge Schumer. Van Hollen led 11 other senators in signing a letter to Schumer and other congressional leaders urging them to rein in military and intelligence cooperation with Israel.
“The agreements and projects these provisions envision threaten U.S. national security interests by handing Israel leverage over American weapons systems and military technology,” the senators wrote.
Israel divides party progressives and moderates. It divides Maryland.
Last month, Annapolis Mayor Jared Littmann refused to sign a memorial citation for the late civic activist Philip Ateto.
Ateto was a vocal critic of Israel’s war in Gaza, which has killed 74,000 Palestinians and displaced 90% of the population. Littmann said Ateto’s criticism crossed into antisemitism.
The mayor eventually issued the citation, but not before people filled the City Council chambers to criticize Israel and Littmann, who is Jewish. The criticism grew so hot that people there said they felt afraid to speak because they were Jewish.
Anger and fear are part of what makes talking about Israel so difficult.

There is anger over both Oct. 7 and the war in Gaza, as well as over Netanyahu’s involvement in the joint attack on Iran. There is fear because that anger sometimes fails to distinguish between criticizing Israel and criticizing the ways some American Jews tie their identity to the Jewish state.
Confusing the two makes the public divide worse and may help explain the despicable increase in antisemitic incidents since Oct. 7, 2023.
Van Hollen’s thinking on Israel has evolved since he was first elected to Congress in 2002. He regularly voted in the House in support of military aid to Israel.
By 2006, as Israel bombarded Hezbollah in Lebanon, Van Hollen began to use language foreshadowing his more potent criticism of the war in Gaza.
“I understand the impulses that are driving Israel’s actions,” he wrote to then-U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, “but I strongly believe that a continuation of the bombing campaign as it is being carried out is against the interests of [Israel] and the United States.”
When he ran for Senate a decade later, Van Hollen was still a mainstream liberal who mostly supported Israel. He beat Rep. Donna Edwards, a much more vocal critic of Israeli policies, in that Democratic primary.
During Van Hollen’s first eight years in the Senate, Israel may have been the only thing that separated him from Sen. Ben Cardin. He opposed Cardin’s efforts to block institutional boycotts and divestment from Israeli companies over the treatment of Palestinians.
Then came Oct. 7 and the war in Gaza.
When Netanyahu addressed a joint session of Congress in 2024, Cardin, who is Jewish and retired later that year, greeted him as a friend. Van Hollen skipped the appearance and offered a blistering critique.
That critique has expanded to Netanyahu’s role in convincing Trump to launch a war against Iran and the influence of AIPAC.
Two years ago, Van Hollen was silent as AIPAC spent $4 million to elect Rep. Sarah Elfreth. By June, he was warning voters about $5 million that AIPAC and cryptocurrency groups were spending on Rep.-elect Adrian Boafo in the 5th District primary.
Senate Democrats’ last contested leadership election was in 1994, when Tom Daschle of South Dakota beat Chris Dodd of Connecticut to become minority leader. The internet was barely a thing; Facebook was a decade away.
This time, public opinion is influencing how this is playing out. It explains the harsh response to Sen. Angela Alsobrooks’ decision to back Schumer. Van Hollen tried to put that in perspective.
“Senator Alsobrooks and I will continue to respect one another and work together on behalf of Marylanders every day,” he said in a statement.
There’s an old movie that’s relevant here. In “The Candidate,” Robert Redford’s character makes a long-shot bid for the Senate because he’s free to speak his mind.
Turns out, that’s what voters wanted and he wins.
If Van Hollen wins, he’ll bring a fresh appraisal of our ties to Israel.
And he’ll have to answer Redford’s final words in the movie: “What do we do now?”






Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.