When he saw the headline, it all came rushing back, the terrible family history that had been long buried.

Richard Mazza scanned the article. A postpartum mom, trying to get help, had killed her kids.

“The first thought I had was, here we go again,” said Mazza, a retired insurance executive in Catonsville.

He was reading about Lindsay Clancy in Massachusetts.

Advertise with us

The hospital nurse in the affluent Boston suburbs — once a devoted mom by all accounts — had strangled her three young children, even the baby, then thrown herself from the second-floor window of their house. Her husband found her paralyzed in the snow, their kids dead or fatally injured inside. He had just come home with takeout.

In Catonsville, Mazza might as well have been reading about another murder case, one 37 years ago, in Western Maryland — the case against his little sister.

Just like Clancy, Anna Maria Rescott was in her early 30s with a new baby, her second son. She, too, sought psychiatric help as her grip on reality slipped. The wrenching details are all too familiar: the kids, methodically suffocated; the mom, bloody and delirious, having survived a suicide attempt. Rescott’s case was a sensation, too. In the jail, they shouted, “Baby killer!”

The two women are separated by a generation and more than 400 miles, yet their sickness took the same path, to the same unthinkable crime. In both cases, the question was the same: not whether a mom killed her kids but whether she was insane when she did it.

Clancy’s murder trial resulted in a hung jury, and the judge declared a mistrial. She returns to court today, as prosecutors push for a retrial.

Advertise with us

Her case has set off fierce debate around the country about postpartum mental health. Hundreds of moms wore pink and packed the courtroom or rallied outside to support her. Yet how could any mother build a snowman with her kids and kill them on the same day? Her crime is inconceivable to the casual observer. Just not to Mazza.

He wrote an email to Clancy’s defense team right away. He wanted them to know the tragic, all-but-forgotten story from Baltimore.

Rescott's older brother, Richard Mazza, recalls his family's experience after his sister killed her two children in the 1980s. For him, Lindsay Clancy's case was a reminder of their family tragedy. (Jerry Jackson/The Banner)

His sister’s case concluded quietly: no trauma relived at trial, no hung jury and no costly mistrial as in Massachusetts.

The State of Maryland vs. Anna Maria Rescott is a reminder that there’s a different path. It’s possible to answer the crimes of a very sick mom another way, with treatment. And, somehow, her life — though tortured — can go on.

The family princess

She was 11 years younger than him and the family princess. Everyone called her “Yonna” from the way her Italian-speaking grandfather stumbled over AHN-nah.

Advertise with us

A popular student at Woodlawn High School in the mid-1970s, she was a favorite neighborhood babysitter. It wasn’t until she was 29 and married with her second baby that her older brother started to worry.

Rescott was showing up late to the family tradition of Sunday spaghetti dinners. She seemed tense and clingy with the boys. When Mazza took her son Brandon for a simple boat ride, she was a wreck, waiting on the docks.

One day, in February 1988, a panicked phone call reached him at work.

Mazza hurried to her brick row house in Halethorpe. He found his older sister, mother and Rescott’s husband locked out on the front porch. She had barricaded herself inside with 6-year-old Brandon and 4-month-old Corey.

Just open up, he urged her. Mazza tried to stay calm, speaking gently through the locked storm door. Was everyone inside OK? Yonna, please.

Advertise with us

The door eased open.

He saw the boys were unharmed, but his sister’s appearance was unnerving. Her hair was a mess and her clothes were dirty, as if she had stopped taking care of herself.

She had been keeping Brandon home from school and carrying the baby through the house as though she didn’t dare put him down. Her husband told Mazza he had seen her walking around with a kitchen knife by her side.

The doctors concluded she was having an episode of major depression with psychotic features. The family admitted her to the psychiatric unit of the University of Maryland Medical Center. Their mother would watch the boys. Mazza was relieved. His nephews were safe; his sister would get help.

She had no history of mental illness. Baffled, Mazza went to search for some medical explanation at the library.

Advertise with us

The psychiatry books described a rare condition called “postpartum psychosis,” in which new moms become depressed, delusional or even psychotic. The pattern can begin as late as weeks after delivery, with the mood changes common around childbirth. Warning signs of a more serious problem are easily brushed off as stress and exhaustion from the new baby. The illness often progresses into insomnia and manic episodes, of exercise or cleaning the fridge, before a full-blown break from reality.

One new mom smelled horses and heard them galloping outside her bedroom, according to a study in the Journal of Women’s Health.

Cases are medically rare, fewer than 2 per 1,000 births, studies show, yet of all the perinatal mood disorders it’s the most dangerous.

The University of Maryland doctors prescribed Rescott antipsychotic and antidepressant medicine. Mazza visited her at the hospital, and she seemed unable to focus her attention. She was anxious and evasive. Her health insurance covered only one month in the facility.

When her discharge arrived, the family met her doctors in a conference room. Mazza pressed them.

Advertise with us

Is she ready? What should the family watch out for? Are the boys safe?

One doctor asked Rescott if she had had any thoughts of hurting her boys or herself. She said “no” quickly, too quickly, almost as if her reply was rehearsed. Mazza wasn’t a doctor, of course, so he kept quiet.

That silence would haunt him for the rest of his life.

A mysterious madness

Some of the earliest and most vivid accounts of postpartum psychosis come from 19th century France.

In a hospital outside Paris, the physician Louis-Victor Marcé noticed a pattern among psychiatric patients after childbirth. The “baby blues” were known, but there was something different about these depressions. He called it a “sad delirium.”

Advertise with us
French psychiatrist Louis-Victor Marcé, 1828-1864. (Lithograph by Emile Desmaisons)

Marcé documented women gripped by insomnia, tormented by hallucinations and obsessed with thoughts of hurting themselves and their babies. His treatise in 1858 on a mysterious madness after childbirth was the first study devoted to postpartum mental illness.

He believed the women’s insanity came not from one cause but a combination of vague, elusive forces — heredity, anemia, malnutrition — that fit together like a puzzle.

More than a century later, the picture wasn’t much clearer.

In Rescott’s case, months went by after her discharge from the hospital but she still didn’t seem like herself.

She had moved in with her mother. Mazza watched his sister lurch from episodes of lucid thought into depression and amped-up anxiety. Worried about what she could do next, the family presented her with a new arrangement.

Advertise with us

They wanted her back in the hospital and to sign over guardianship of the boys.

“I think that was what triggered her. I really do,” Mazza said.

Within a few days, on Oct. 24, 1988, Rescott told her mother she was going to buy Corey a snowsuit and left with the baby. Mazza’s phone rang hours later with the call he had dreaded. Rescott had run off.

He immediately called Brandon’s school, only to learn his sister had signed out the boy hours earlier. His next phone call was to police.

Rescott’s psychologist wrote to law enforcement, warning that she may be dangerous to herself or others. Mazza went on TV, appealing for help to find her. He braced for the worst.

Advertise with us

Three days later, police called him. Brandon and Corey were dead. His sister was missing.

Mazza hurried to his mother’s house and asked for a police chaplain. Only later, from investigators, would he learn the wrenching details.

Rescott had driven the boys about 130 miles to Cumberland. Under the name of “Julie Simpson,” she checked into the Holiday Inn.

She told the boys they were playing a game when she duct-taped their mouths. Then she smothered them with a pillow, killing Brandon first so he could introduce his baby brother to their grandfather in heaven. She cut herself with a razor and went to sleep in a warm bath to die. Only the next morning, she woke up in the tub.

Rescott changed hotels and tried to kill herself again. The desk clerk called police when she came down wearing wet and bloody clothes. Disoriented, she went into the dining room and ordered coffee and a salad.

Advertise with us

State police troopers saw slashes to her wrists, arms and neck. She needed two pints of blood, according to court papers. Rescott told police she believed both of her sons were dead and she didn’t know why she had done it.

The phone kept ringing at his mother’s house with calls from reporters, police and attorneys. With their father deceased, Mazza was the head of the family. He had to be strong and keep his composure.

Only when he was alone in the shower would he let himself break down and cry.

In the hospital, staff counted 52 wounds on Rescott’s body, some cuts to the bone.

When the family got to her room, she was on suicide watch and also guarded in case one of them sought retribution. Mazza said they weren’t angry, though. They had lost the boys, but they could still save her — or try to.

Advertise with us

Mazza told her they had hired a lawyer. She was crying a little.

He walked over and hugged her.

‘We know it wasn’t her’

The study of postpartum psychiatric illness all but ended in the early 20th century. The very word “postpartum” was considered outdated to modern psychiatry, wrote the late Dr. James Alexander Hamilton, a psychiatry professor at Stanford University School of Medicine, in his 1992 book “Postpartum Psychiatric Illness: A Picture Puzzle.”

He helped organize the International Marcé Society for Perinatal Mental Health, named for the 19th century French doctor, to bring new attention to mental illness after childbirth. Hamilton worried that awareness and study of postpartum psychosis would end following a decision in 1980 to remove it as a stand-alone disorder from psychiatry’s bible, the “Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.”

DSM authors deleted the postpartum references, believing it was better to categorize disorders by symptoms rather than causes. The new method did not distinguish perinatal mood disorders from depression and psychosis not associated with childbirth.

Advertise with us

“When postpartum illness lost its name,” Hamilton wrote, “it was abolished from the thinking of Medicine and Psychiatry.”

The problem carried into the courts. When postpartum moms harm their babies, judges and jurors oftentimes struggle to accept an insanity defense, particularly when it rests on a disorder without a name.

“Because it doesn’t appear in the DSM, women have a really hard time pleading an insanity defense for judges to take it seriously,” said Dr. Susan Feingold, a clinical psychologist in Chicago, on the podcast “Perinatal and Reproductive Perspectives.”

Feingold helped convince the Illinois Legislature to pass a law in 2018 allowing moms locked up for postpartum psychosis crimes to petition for new sentences. There were about 20 such moms in Illinois prisons at the time, and several have been released. Feingold and others have lobbied additional states to pass legislation recognizing postpartum illness as a factor in criminal cases.

Clancy’s monthlong trial this summer centered on competing theories about her state of mind. A psychiatrist who testified for the state referred to postpartum psychosis as merely a proposed disorder and noted its absence from the DSM. The state’s experts described Clancy not as delusional but calculating, and they offered a theory of “altruistic filicide,” or killing one’s kids out of love. She felt compelled to kill herself, they said, and believed her children would suffer without her.

Advertise with us

Defense expert witnesses argued that Clancy suffered postpartum psychosis — “frankly psychotic,” one doctor even put it — and heard voices commanding her to kill the children.

Eleven of the 12 jurors sided with the defense, concluding Clancy was not criminally responsible for her children’s deaths. But, amid the competing theories, one juror held out and caused the mistrial.

In October 1988, Rescott also faced life in prison on multiple counts of first-degree murder.

Just as with Clancy, anyone could see Rescott was sick. The question before doctors, however, was whether her illness made her insane under the strict requirements of Maryland law. Known as “not criminally responsible,” Maryland’s insanity defense, just like Massachusetts’, is reserved for people who lack the “substantial capacity” to understand they’re committing a crime or to conform their behavior to the law.

And, just like Clancy’s family, Rescott’s believed she was not criminally responsible.

Advertise with us
A newspaper clipping from the Baltimore Sun in 1989, with the headline “Woman who killed 2 sons not criminally responsible”. In the photo, Anna Maria Rescott holds her son, Corey. (Baltimore Sun)

“We know that she is a very sick woman and are supporting her as much as we possibly can,” Mazza told reporters outside a pretrial hearing. “We know it wasn’t her. She has not been thinking rationally.”

After her arrest, his sister was taken to the Clifton T. Perkins Hospital Center, the state’s maximum-security psychiatric hospital in Jessup. The staff psychiatrists determined she had suffered months of intrusive thoughts about killing herself and her boys — thoughts she knew were wrong, but she couldn’t resist. Unlike in Clancy’s case, the state’s doctors agreed ahead of any possible trial that Rescott met the requirements of the insanity defense.

Still, the decision of whether to accept her plea rested with an Allegany County judge.

“This case represents one of the most tragic occurrences ever presented to this court. The loss of such young lives is immeasurable,” Allegany Circuit Judge Gary G. Leasure said. “It seems to me unimaginable that a reasoning, rational person could ever commit these acts on her children.”

The judge accepted her insanity plea. There would be no frontier justice in the mountains of Western Maryland.

He committed her to the state psychiatric hospital indefinitely.

If only someone had asked

The maximum-security hospital seemed like prison to Mazza. Only his sister was called a “patient” and she didn’t wear a gray jumpsuit.

When the hospital had a cookout for families, he met one of her friends. Mazza had heard the man set fire to his house with his family inside. They just talked baseball.

Rescott had found a community without judgment. She filled 16 journals with her thoughts.

“I blame many professionals for what happened. Why didn’t someone ask me how I was feeling, what I was thinking? If someone would have asked, I might have told them. I need help to understand why this happened,” she wrote.

While committed, she separated from her husband and sued her family therapist and the University of Maryland doctors who had treated her before the killings. Her lawsuit accused them of misdiagnosing her illness as depression only and ending her treatment of antipsychotic medication.

This negligence, she alleged, directly caused the deaths of her boys. It was a novel case for Maryland, likely the first time a criminally insane defendant blamed her killings on medical malpractice, The Baltimore Sun reported.

Clancy has sued her doctors, too, alleging a “a catastrophic failure” to diagnose and treat her postpartum psychiatric condition.

In Rescott’s case, the judge dismissed the lawsuit, finding it was not reasonably foreseeable to her doctors that she would kill her kids. Still, her lawsuit signaled a shift. Rescott didn’t blame herself entirely anymore.

After she spent four years in the hospital, doctors no longer considered her dangerous to herself or others. The judge ordered her to meet strict new conditions, such as taking her medicine, attending daytime programs and living with her mother. In March 1993, Rescott went home.

Every day afterward, Mazza tensed when the phone rang unexpectedly.

He was always afraid his sister was going to die by suicide.

Lifting the silence

Rescott did a little office work for a construction company. After her mother died, she moved out and rented an apartment in Sykesville. She didn’t marry or have children again, but she had her rescue dogs, Autumn then Jezzie.

The Mazzas came together on holidays. No one ever spoke of what had happened.

Mazza didn’t know Rescott was gathering strength from a network of moms imprisoned around the country. A pen pal group began around 1990 to connect the moms, as many as 35 at one time, locked up for postpartum killings.

Debra Gindorf was serving a life sentence in Illinois for killing her toddler and baby with crushed sleeping pills. Dawn March was locked up in a Connecticut psychiatric hospital for throwing her baby in the river. Elizabeth Pacchioli was in a Pennsylvania prison for smothering her baby in a garbage bag.

“I know how special and precious my family is, but they don’t understand what I’m going through,” Rescott wrote about the network for Postpartum Support International, in letters stored at the University of California, Santa Barbara, archives. “The women in the Network of Penpals understand. My true healing began when I was put in contact with these women.”

Dawn Baynes with her son and Anna Maria Rescott.
Dawn Baynes, right, with her son and Anna Maria Rescott. (Courtesy of Dawn Baynes)

Baltimore County mom Dawn Baynes credits Rescott with saving her from her own postpartum psychosis scare years ago. Baynes went days without sleeping or eating and suffered intrusive thoughts about hurting her son. She wrote to Rescott for help.

Jane Honikman, who started the pen pal group, has done decades of postpartum work, and she’s seen many Lindsay Clancys. She considers Rescott’s case among the best possible outcomes.

“Without a doubt in my mind,” she said. “It was humane and just, and it should be an example of how we should be approaching these cases.”

In Plymouth, Massachusetts, the district attorney hasn’t revealed if he will reduce the charges against Clancy. Her three counts of first-degree murder bring a mandatory life sentence without the possibility of parole.

“That’s my heartache,” Honikman said. “I see the inconsistencies: state by state, county by county, judge by judge. … Why don’t we make any progress?”

In Baltimore County, Mazza would watch his sister drift away around the anniversary of the killings. Her boys were buried in the family plot in Elkridge. There’s one grave marker; Brandon and Corey are together.

Rescott would visit on their birthdays and Christmas or just sunny days. She would bring a little bouquet. She liked the warm colors of the autumn flowers best. She might kneel and brush the cut grass off the boys’ gravestone.

She was 62 when she died of cancer in late 2020. She chose not to be buried with her boys. Instead, she hoped doctors might learn from her illness to stop it from hurting another mom. She donated her body to medical research.

Then there was no more phone call for Mazza to fear. For more than 30 years, he avoided mention of the killings to protect his baby sister. Now Mazza had something to say.

The family was firmly against his idea to write about their painful history. A book was a door to a place that no one wanted to revisit. Mazza self-published the book last year anyway, changing the places and the names. Only the epilogue hints at a brother’s purpose.

“The purpose is fulfilled,” he wrote, “if even one life is saved because someone read it.”

Know the signs: If you or someone you know may be experiencing postpartum depression or another perinatal mental health condition, call or text the Postpartum Support International HelpLine at 1-800-944-4773 (English and Spanish), visit postpartum.net, or download the Connect by PSI mobile app. No diagnosis is needed to reach out for support.

Postpartum psychosis is a medical emergency. If you or someone you know is exhibiting symptoms, seek immediate medical attention.