A Baltimore County judge on Tuesday, in a rare move, granted a new trial for a former Catholic priest convicted of sexually abusing a student in the 1990s, but only on two of the five counts.

A jury found William Mannion Jr. guilty on Oct. 8 in Baltimore County Circuit Court of one count of child abuse and four counts of second-degree sex offense. His attorneys, Charles Waechter and Christopher Luber, argued that the entire verdict was contrary to the evidence.

Circuit Judge Dennis Robinson Jr. awarded Mannion a new trial on two counts of second-degree sex offense because the evidence showed he started working at St. Agnes Catholic School in Catonsville after the indictment alleges that those crimes took place.

But Robinson ruled that the verdict on the three remaining counts should stand, allowing the case to proceed to sentencing on Dec. 14

Advertise with us

As a result, Deputy State’s Attorney Lisa Dever dropped the two counts of second-degree sex offense at issue instead of opting to retry them. It’s unclear what practical effect, if any, the ruling will have on the sentence in the case.

Prosecutors allege that Mannion, 64, of Sparrows Point, repeatedly pulled the student and altar server out of class and sexually assaulted him in the rectory during the school day. The survivor testified that the abuse stopped when his family moved out of state.

The Banner does not identify survivors of sexual assault without their permission.

In 1998, Mannion left the priesthood, got married and became a father. He worked at Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical Center as a case manager before becoming a nurse in the psychiatric unit.

The case divided the local Catholic community, with some pointing out how Mannion helped bring down the notorious child rapist John Merzbacher, who worked as a teacher at the Catholic Community School of Baltimore and victimized dozens of children.

Advertise with us

Merzbacher, 81, died in 2023 while serving four life sentences.

Mannion is being held in the Baltimore County Detention Center while he awaits sentencing.