Thousands of times a year, people in Baltimore call 911 and then hang up or get disconnected. Baltimore Police are supposed to check it out by calling back, and if there’s no answer, an officer is supposed to go to the location of the call.
But too often, that hasn’t been happening.
Baltimore Police say they are now mandating that these no-voice 911 calls be dispatched to a patrol unit and that an officer respond to the scene.
“While these calls are a reality of emergency communications, each no-voice call must be handled through an appropriate process to ensure that a person who may need help is not overlooked,” Baltimore Police chief spokesperson Lindsey Eldridge said. She did not characterize how widespread the problem may be.
The issue was first raised by Officer Jordan Thomas, who was suspended for unrelated conduct and placed in the department’s Telephone Reporting Unit, where he said he noticed a trend of officers “coding out” calls to 911 when the person hung up and did not respond to callbacks from police. “Coding out” is when an officer tells a dispatcher they are not going to respond to a call.
Patrol officers were supposed to determine in person whether an emergency response was needed, but many times that didn’t happen, according to Thomas’ findings filed in court papers.
Read More
“The field officers and the supervisors, and sometimes the dispatchers, are engaging in a neglectful pattern in which callers who may actually be in trouble will never see a police response,” Thomas wrote in a complaint he sent to oversight authorities, including the team monitoring implementation of the 2017 federal consent decree requiring reforms to Baltimore Police.
Kenneth Thompson, lead of the monitoring team, wrote in an email to The Banner this week that “while the issue raised in the complaint is important, it is not one that generally falls within the scope of the Consent Decree.”
Thomas also included the complaint in a lawsuit he filed against the Police Department related to his employment and alleged harassment by supervisors, which predated his observations in the telephone reporting unit.
In most cases, Thomas wrote that he didn’t know whether someone actually needed assistance. But he cited examples from successful follow-up calls where it turned out there was indeed trouble, including one where children had made the call because their pregnant mother had fallen and needed to be taken to a hospital.

Thomas, who declined an interview, wrote that the practice appeared to be longstanding, noting that a 2020 staffing report said there were 79,780 911 hang-up calls in 2018 and only 3,811 of them were said to have generated a response from a patrol officer. It was not clear from the report how many of those calls were affected by officers “coding out” and not following up in person.
The Banner asked police to respond to the claims, and the department acknowledged that Thomas had identified a problem.
“We recognize that this practice needs to be corrected, and we are taking steps to address it,” Eldridge said.
She cautioned that there were legitimate reasons that a call might not be followed up on. Some of those reasons include multiple calls for the same incident, call locations being listed at a cell tower rather than in a general area, and competing demands on general call volume.
But she said “those circumstances should not eliminate the need for an appropriate response.”
How it works
Baltimore Police expanded its Telephone Reporting Unit in 2022, in part due to ongoing staffing woes, to handle non-emergency calls for service that do not require an in-person officer response.
When someone calls 911 and the call drops, dispatchers are generally still able to determine where the call came from. The telephone reporting unit is tasked with calling back three times, and if they’re unable to reach anyone, the call is sent to patrol to determine whether an emergency exists.
“There have been instances where contact was able to be made during a 911 no voice call by myself, and it was determined the caller was injured,” Thomas wrote.
“Or needed an ambulance because they were elderly and facing some sort of medical issue. Or because someone was actively being assaulted. Or because children were trying to call emergency services for their mother. Or even because serious bodily injury such as a gunshot was inflicted on someone.”
Eldridge, the Police Department spokesperson, said an estimated 10% to 20% of incoming 911 calls nationwide are accidental or misdialed calls.
The department is now reviewing and updating its standard operating procedures, providing additional training for dispatch personnel, and implementing measures to reinforce expectations within the patrol division, according to Eldridge.
If a specific address cannot be established for an in-person visit, officers are required to conduct an appropriate area check, she said. Only after these steps have been completed may the call be cleared.
She noted that a new director of communications was recently hired and will be conducting a comprehensive review of communications policies and procedures.
Raised by suspended officer
Thomas, the suspended officer, brought the issues to light, but his six years with the department have been rocky.
Baltimore Police moved to revoke his certification as a police officer earlier this year, telling the Maryland Police Training and Standards Commission that he had engaged in “repeated violations of police department policies” and “conduct that may implicate constitutional and statutory concerns.”
“Officer Thomas’ documented incidents include, but are not limited to, unlawful searches and seizures, failure to activate body-worn camera equipment, unsafe vehicle operation, improper use of force, failure to report use-of-force incidents, and conduct adversely affecting public safety, supervisory trust, and operational effectiveness,” the training commission wrote in a summary of the Police Department’s claims against Thomas.
Thomas, representing himself, filed a federal lawsuit against the Police Department, alleging retaliation by supervisors who called him an “action junkie.”
Thomas said he has been “repeatedly subjected to shifting narratives, inconsistent discipline, retaliatory treatment, public ridicule, and reliance upon false rumors.”
While awaiting a resolution of his disciplinary cases, Thomas collected his observations about the 911 calls and submitted them as a complaint. It became public after he attached it as an exhibit to his lawsuit, in support of his claim to whistleblower protection.




Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.